Regret index
How likely each signing is to be seen later as a mistake, out of 100. Higher means more regret. It looks at how far he is below the club's target, whether better options were missed, how well he fits, how big the bet was and whether the problem keeps showing. Tap a player to see the stats behind his score.
How many signings in each group
- 1Brennan Johnson
NFO→
TOTHigh regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample65regret - 2Axel DisasiAS AS Monaco→
CHEHigh regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample62regret - 3Jaden Philogene
AVL→
HULModerate regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample58regret - 4Djordje PetrovicNEWNew England Revolution→
CHEModerate regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample57regret - 5Daniel MuñozRACRacing Genk→
CRYModerate regretPlayed 6% of possible minutes in 1 gameSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample54regret - 6Pedro PorroSPOSporting CP→
TOTModerate regretPlayed 37% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample50regret - 7Youri TielemansLEILeicester City→
AVLModerate regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample49regret - 8Pau TorresVILVillarreal→
AVLModerate regretPlayed 52% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample45regret - 9Jefferson Lerma
BOU→
CRYModerate regretPlayed 28% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample43regret - 10Ryan GravenberchBAYBayern Munich→
LIVLimited regretPlayed 38% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample39regret - 11Sandro TonaliAC AC Milan→
NEWLimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample37regret - 12Carlos BalebaLILLille→
BHALimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample34regret - 13Moisés Caicedo
BHA→
CHELimited regretPlayed 49% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample33regret - 14Matz SelsSTRStrasbourg→
NFOLimited regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence32regret - 15Nicolas JacksonVILVillarreal→
CHELimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample32regret - 16Ian Maatsen
CHE→
AVLLimited regretPlayed 67% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence32regret - 17Tyler Adams
LEE→
BOULimited regretPlayed 81% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence30regret - 18Tim Iroegbunam
AVL→
EVELimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 1 gameSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample30regret - 19Nathan CollinsWOLWolverhampton Wanderers→
BRELimited regretPlayed 27% of possible minutes in 4 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample30regret - 20Jurriën TimberAJAAjax Amsterdam→
ARSLimited regretPlayed 37% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample28regret - 21Justin KluivertAS AS Roma→
BOULimited regretPlayed 58% of possible minutes in 8 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample27regret - 22Anthony Elanga
MAN→
NFOLimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample26regret - 23Ola AinaTORTorino→
NFOLimited regretPlayed 49% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample25regret - 24Jérémy DokuSTAStade Rennais→
MNCLimited regretPlayed 44% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample21regret - 25Dean Henderson
MAN→
CRYLow regretPlayed 50% of possible minutes in 5 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample18regret - 26Morgan RogersMIDMiddlesbrough→
AVLLow regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample16regret - 27Matheus NunesWOLWolverhampton Wanderers→
MNCLow regretPlayed 57% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample15regret - 28Bobby ThomasBURBurnley→
COVLow regretPlayed 75% of possible minutes in 8 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence10regret - 29Calvin BasseyAJAAjax Amsterdam→
FULLow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence7regret - 30Ethan Ampadu
CHE→
LEELow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence7regret - 31MurilloCORCorinthians→
NFOLow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence5regret - 32Josko GvardiolRB RB Leipzig→
MNCLow regretPlayed 78% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence1regret - 33Adam WhartonBLABlackburn Rovers→
CRYLow regretPlayed 98% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 34Alex Iwobi
EVE→
FULLow regretPlayed 92% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 35Cole Palmer
MNC→
CHELow regretPlayed 98% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 36Timothy CastagneLEILeicester City→
FULLow regretPlayed 84% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 37Romeo LaviaSOUSouthampton→
CHELow regretPlayed 51% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 38Alex ScottBRIBristol City→
BOULow regretPlayed 50% of possible minutes in 5 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 39Micky van de VenVFLVfL Wolfsburg→
TOTLow regretPlayed 82% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 40Harvey BarnesLEILeicester City→
NEWLow regretPlayed 99% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 41Milos KerkezAZ AZ Alkmaar→
BOULow regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 42Declan RiceWESWest Ham United→
ARSLow regretPlayed 92% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 43Bart VerbruggenANDAnderlecht→
BHALow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 44Dominik SzoboszlaiRB RB Leipzig→
LIVLow regretPlayed 64% of possible minutes in 8 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 45Kevin SchadeSC SC Freiburg→
BRELow regretPlayed 87% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret
The number on the left is the rank: 1 is the most regretted. Circle colour compares the signings on this list, red for the most regret and green for the least. The words under each name give the absolute level.
19 signings are not scored yet. Missing evidence is left out, never counted as zero.
Sporting delivery measured against the role a signing was meant to fill. Fees are not used, so this is not a financial ROI. The Regret Index is an evidence-based signal, not a verdict on a club's decision. Weights and thresholds are starting hypotheses.









































