How scores work
A plain guide to the numbers on the Delivery, Regret and Clubs pages. No transfer fees are used anywhere, because fees are unknown for most moves and we never guess them.
Where the numbers come from
- His games since joining. Match-by-match facts after every game: minutes, goals, assists, shots, chances created and cards. We save them, so we can count only the games since he joined his new club.
- His full season. Season totals for every Premier League player, including expected goals and assists, clean sheets, defensive actions, saves and fitness news.
- We look at both sets of stats every time and use both. If one is not available, the other is used and the page says so.
The delivery score (out of 100)
It answers one question: how much has he given the club since joining? Four parts are marked out of 100 and combined:
- Match performance, 45%. How his numbers compare with other players in the same position. 50 is typical, 80 is excellent. It is the average of two ratings: one from his games since joining and one from his season stats.
- Playing time, 25%. The share of the minutes on offer that he has played. If the team played 1,000 minutes since he joined and he played 700, that is 70.
- Steady form, 15%. How often his rating has stayed at or near the level the club expected.
- Fitness record, 15%. How often he was fit to be picked. Time out injured or suspended is not held against him as “not selected”. This part only counts once the team has checked his absences.
If a part has no evidence yet, it is left out and the rest is rescaled. It is never counted as zero. The page shows how much of the evidence is in.
How performance is judged, by position
A goalkeeper and a striker are never judged on the same numbers. Each player is ranked only against others in his own position, then given a rank from 0 to 100.
Measures from season stats
- Goalkeepers: Saves per 90 minutes, Clean sheets per 90, Goals conceded per 90 (fewer is better).
- Defenders: Clean sheets per 90, Defensive actions per 90, Chances allowed per 90 (fewer is better), Goal threat per 90.
- Midfielders: Goals per 90, Assists per 90, Goal threat per 90, Chance creation per 90, Defensive actions per 90.
- Forwards: Goals per 90, Assists per 90, Expected goals per 90, Goal threat per 90.
Measures from his games since joining
Goals, assists, shots, chances created, minutes played and cards, weighted for his role (goalkeeper, centre-back, full-back, defensive midfielder, central midfielder, attacking midfielder or winger, forward). A forward is rewarded mostly for goals and shots, a midfielder for passes that create chances, and a defender is marked down for cards.
“Per 90” means for every full match of 90 minutes, so a player with fewer minutes is judged fairly. With little playing time a rank is pulled toward 50, so a few good games cannot make anyone look like a star. Season stats need 450 minutes and his games since joining need about 180 before a rank counts.
The target he is measured against
Delivery is compared with the job the club signed him to do:
- First-team starter
75 - Regular rotation
65 - Squad depth
55 - Young prospect
45
The gap is his delivery minus the target. Ten or more above is clearly above expectations, within ten either way is about what was expected, ten to twenty below is below expectations, and twenty or more below is a serious shortfall. Until the team records the real job, players aged 20 or under are assumed to be young prospects and everyone else regular rotation. This is shown on the page.
The regret index (out of 100)
Higher means more reason to regret the signing. It is a signal to look closer, not proof the club made a mistake at the time.
- Below the target, 35%. How far his delivery is under what the club expected.
- Better options missed, 25%. Only counted when the team has recorded a real alternative who was available at the time and why he was comparable.
- Role fit, 15%. How badly he suits the job, as assessed by the team with a written reason.
- Size of the bet, 15%. An estimate of the club's commitment (elite, major, strategic, developmental or opportunistic). It is not a fee.
- How long it has lasted, 10%. Whether he has been below target in most of the last few checks. It needs at least three checks over three weeks.
Groups: 0 to 20 low regret, 21 to 40 limited, 41 to 60 moderate, 61 to 80 high, 81 to 100 severe. On the Regret page the most regretted signing is first with a red circle, and the least regretted has a green one.
How much to trust a score
- Solid evidence: 1,500 or more minutes played since joining.
- Fair amount of evidence: 600 to 1,499 minutes.
- Early read: under 600 minutes, or joined less than 60 days ago. It can still change a lot.
Club pages always show how many signings were scored, because two scored signings are not the same evidence as twenty. All weights and limits are starting values that we will test and adjust as real results come in.